When Kelly O’Connell arrived in New York after faculty in 2007, she landed in Astoria, Queens, and shortly discovered every little thing she wanted — associates, meals and purchasing. “You don’t want to enter Manhattan in your time without work to do something,” she mentioned. “Astoria is like its personal little metropolis insulated from town.”
Shortly earlier than the pandemic, Ms. O’Connell was working at a theatrical rigging firm when she interviewed Steven Ferrier, newly arrived from Chicago, for a job. He declined, however the two began courting and Mr. Ferrier finally joined Ms. O’Connell in Astoria, the place they rented an house for $2,100 a month.
[Did you recently buy a home? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com]
The couple spent the pandemic within the closet-free railroad unit. The lengthy, slim structure felt more and more claustrophobic, and as Covid receded, they fearful that their landlord would increase the lease.
The couple acquired married final 12 months and resolved to purchase a house, trying first in Astoria and close by Lengthy Island Metropolis, with a funds of as much as $650,000. They have been shocked to seek out that locations on the market appeared no higher than locations for lease. They discovered principally small walkups in older co-op buildings removed from public transportation.
They requested themselves what was actually necessary and settled on simply two issues: an excellent work commute and a dishwasher. Every part else was negotiable.
“We wouldn’t cook dinner a lot as a result of we each hate washing dishes,” Ms. O’Connell mentioned.
Pissed off with Astoria’s choices, Mr. Ferrier recommended they contemplate Midtown Manhattan, the place they might each stroll to their jobs.
Ms. O’Connell, 39, now works as the overall supervisor of The Journey, a tour bus firm in Instances Sq.. Mr. Ferrier, 40, is a member of the Broadway stagehand union, IATSE Native One, and works primarily within the theater district. His hours are lengthy and irregular, and he typically lugs a heavy software case.
“It could be an hour and quarter-hour to take a prepare house,” he mentioned. The 2 barely noticed one another.
The co-ops they present in Midtown (they averted probably the most crowded areas, like Instances Sq. and Hell’s Kitchen) have been greater and nicer than those they’d seen in Queens, with higher facilities and decrease buy costs, however larger month-to-month upkeep prices.
“Abruptly the alternatives appeared limitless as a substitute of 1 midway respectable house a grandmother had died in,” Ms. O’Connell mentioned. “It was bonkers.”
The 2 have been referred to Yan Gladkov, a licensed salesperson at Keller Williams NYC. “We stored the radius of their search tremendous tight,” Mr. Gladkov mentioned. They aimed for the West 50s, and nicknamed each place they checked out.
Usually, locations didn’t dwell as much as the listings, with skilled pictures that turned darkish into gentle, small into massive, slim into huge. Mr. Ferrier was scrupulous about checking fixtures, testing each faucet, knob and light-weight. “He has by no means met a element he can’t obsess over,” Ms.O’Connell mentioned. “He at all times has his multi-tool on him.”
At one level, he encountered a kitchen drawer that didn’t open correctly. “It had come off its slider and a retaining ring had popped out,” Mr. Ferrier mentioned. So he mounted it.
Ms. O’Connell was extra hands-off. “It could by no means happen to me to flush a bathroom in a stranger’s house,” she mentioned. “I used to be hesitant to open a closet as a result of it felt so invasive.”
Discover out what occurred subsequent by answering these two questions:
