When Dubravka Wahl first laid eyes on her distinctive Florida residence in 2023, she immediately fell in love. Not simply with the prime beachfront location and double-lot property—however with the distinctive pirate-inspired structure that lent the property its signature Keys really feel.
“It was completely beautiful,” she recollects of the $2 million residence, which is suitably situated on Jolly Roger Drive. “I assumed, ‘Wow, craftsmanship, a masterpiece.'”
Nonetheless, upon additional inspection of the property, Wahl was left horrified by its derelict situation. The Cudjoe Key dwelling, which was accomplished in 1982, hadn’t been up to date in almost 50 years and he or she remembers considering what a “dump” it was, including that it appeared “so scary.”
However that didn’t drive her away—in reality, it solely served to persuade her that she was the proper individual to take over the house.
It was that keenness that in the end secured her the property; whereas many buyers and builders have been flocking to the Keys in search of getting older houses that they may tear down and change with trendy mansions, Wahl noticed one thing value preserving.
“Everybody else who made a suggestion wished to tear it down as a result of it sits on two heaps, 14,000 sq. ft whole, however the earlier proprietor was heartbroken at that concept,” she defined.
“Her father, an architect from Massachusetts, constructed it as a trip residence within the early Nineteen Eighties. She advised me, ‘Whoever guarantees to not tear it down will get the home.’ So I did, and that’s why I received it.”
Wahl undertook an intensive renovation, restoring the house to its former glory and adapting it for contemporary Florida dwelling. She even put in air con, one thing the earlier proprietor had surprisingly resisted.
“Nothing structural wanted altering, however every little thing else was outdated,” she defined. “I put in new air con and restored it with respect for the unique design. It’s a house constructed for a subtropical atmosphere … there’s 26-foot ceilings in the principle room and even 16-foot ceilings within the bogs, so the warmth rises naturally.”
The unique craftsmanship additionally ensures that the property will stand the take a look at of time, resisting the ravages of the native local weather.
“What’s wonderful is that it was constructed with Florida lumber, Dade pine and cedar, which is ideal for this local weather,” Wahl added. “It has balconies, catwalks, and that stunning bridge connecting the 2 higher bedrooms. It’s so charming.”
Now in her later years, Wahl is promoting the house, citing each private causes and a broader shift in a group that she feels priced out of.
“After I first got here to the Florida Keys almost 40 years in the past, individuals have been social. You’d go to neighbors, host little festivals. Now individuals keep behind closed doorways, entertained by their gadgets. You don’t even see youngsters enjoying outdoors anymore. The sense of group has actually pale,” she mentioned.
Wahl blames that shift on the COVID-19 pandemic, when an inflow of newcomers arrived within the Keys, altering the face of the group—each by way of its aesthetics and its really feel.
“COVID modified every little thing. In the course of the pandemic, individuals wished to get out of cities, and the Keys felt protected, it was simply bridges connecting small islands,” she mentioned.
“So individuals found it. However now, should you can afford to construct a $5 or $6 million home right here, you’re in all probability not working within the Keys; you’re in New York or Abu Dhabi. That’s who’s shopping for it now.”
Rising property taxes have compounded the problem for long-term residents—together with Wahl, who mentioned her renovation of the house solely served to extend her payments.
“After I purchased this residence, taxes have been low as a result of it was falling aside. Now that I’ve restored it, the tax assessor tripled them,” she revealed. “It’s driving aged individuals like me out. We’re on fastened incomes, we will’t afford that.”
Hikes in property taxes have turn out to be a scorching button political subject within the state, with many residents struggling to maintain up. That’s why politicians like Gov. Ron DeSantis proposed eliminating property taxes within the state earlier this 12 months.
Simply final week the Florida Home rolled out a collection of proposed constitutional amendments to chop property taxes, together with the DeSantis-backed concept of eliminating them of their entirety, which state residents will get to vote on within the 2026 poll.
Wahl, who’s a fan of famed architects like Frank Lloyd Wright, laments that character houses like hers are more and more being changed by trendy “concrete bunkers” as new residents with deep pockets shift to the realm.
“They’re constructing what I name ‘concrete bunkers’—large, white, metal, boxy houses with no appeal. They seem like dental workplaces. The structure has misplaced its soul,” she mentioned.
Though Wahl can not assure the house will stay intact beneath new possession, she hopes potential patrons will rethink demolition.
“My message to patrons is easy: Rethink tearing down. Add on, renovate, increase—don’t destroy,” she urged.
The house Wahl is promoting, which is filled with the pirate appeal she adores, is listed at $1.99 million—and is a uncommon oceanfront providing on the decrease Keys. Nestled on almost 0.16 acres (roughly 6,970 sq. ft) of waterfront land, it options 4 bedrooms and three full bogs throughout roughly 2,440 sq. ft of dwelling house.
Constructed on concrete stilts in 1982 and totally renovated, the property is resilient towards hurricane-driven surge and tidal challenges.
The house boasts high-impact doorways and home windows, new air con, recent flooring, and a customized kitchen with granite counter tops and stainless-steel home equipment, mixing trendy methods with unique architectural character.
The cathedral-ceilinged dwelling and eating space opens through a number of sliders to a lined porch of roughly 500 sq. ft, providing panoramic ocean views and a seamless indoor-outdoor way of life. The double-lot footprint and use of Dade pine and cedar present each structural significance and enduring appeal.
Whereas Wahl is gloomy to half together with her pirate-ship-inspired residence, the sale represents a possibility for a purchaser to protect a basic Outdated Florida Keys residence in a primary oceanfront location.
